Best MLB DFS Picks Today: Top Value Plays for May 15, 2026

Friday night brings one of the biggest MLB slates of the season, with 15 games on the board headlined by the annual Rivalry Weekend matchups. Yankees at Mets, Cubs at White Sox, Royals at Cardinals, Rangers at Astros, Orioles at Nationals, and Dodgers at Angels are all in play, giving DFS players an embarrassment of riches when it comes to lineup construction options. Whether you’re playing cash games or firing multi-entry GPP tournaments, the sheer volume of games means there are high-quality plays at every price point.

Bet $5+ Get $100 In Bonus Bets Instantly

View Offer

The approach today is straightforward: lock in the best pitcher on the slate at the top price, stack against a struggling arm in a hitter-friendly environment, and sprinkle in mid-range value plays who are getting on base and producing at a per-dollar rate that is impossible to ignore. Let’s break down the five picks that anchor the best DraftKings lineup for today’s MLB DFS slate.

Cam Schlittler, SP — New York Yankees ($10,500 DraftKings)

There is no debate about who the top pitcher on today’s slate is. Cam Schlittler has been arguably the best starting pitcher in all of baseball to begin 2026, and his resume backs that up with hard numbers. Through nine starts, the Yankees right-hander carries a 1.35 ERA, 0.81 WHIP, and 59 strikeouts over 53.1 innings — good for a 10.0 K/9 rate. His 5-1 record understates the dominance. He leads all qualified MLB starters in ERA and sits second in WHIP, putting him firmly in the AL Cy Young conversation.

Tonight he draws the New York Mets, who have been the worst offensive team in baseball this season. The Mets rank last in team OPS and are battling the San Francisco Giants for the basement in runs scored. That is the dream matchup for a power pitcher at the top of the board. At $10,500 on DraftKings, Schlittler projects as the highest-ceiling play on today’s slate and should anchor the majority of winning GPP lineups. He’s pitching at Citi Field in Queens, a neutral-to-pitcher-friendly park, which only adds to the appeal. Pay up without hesitation.

Shea Langeliers, C/1B — Athletics ($5,900 DraftKings)

If Schlittler is the easy call at the top, Shea Langeliers is the easy call in the middle. The Athletics catcher is having a monster 2026 season, hitting .340 with a 1.020 OPS, 12 home runs, and 27 RBIs through 39 games. He leads Oakland’s entire roster in nearly every offensive category and has been one of the most productive fantasy assets regardless of position. Last season he posted 30-plus home runs and 30-plus doubles, and his power has carried over into this year without missing a beat.

Tonight the Athletics are in Sacramento against the San Francisco Giants, playing at Sutter Health Park. That temporary home has played as one of the most hitter-friendly environments in baseball this season, with the short dimensions and high elevation contributing to inflated offensive numbers. Langeliers projects as the top-rated catcher on the slate at $5,900 with an expected DraftKings value of 1.86, and his ability to play catcher or first base provides critical lineup flexibility. At his price, he is one of the better raw plays on the board from a pure production-per-dollar standpoint.

Bobby Witt Jr., SS — Kansas City Royals ($5,900 DraftKings)

Bobby Witt Jr. has quietly put together one of the best offensive seasons in the American League. Through 43 games in 2026, the Kansas City shortstop is hitting .306 with a .378 OBP, .506 slugging percentage, 7 home runs, 12 stolen bases, and 22 RBIs. His wRC+ of 142 puts him comfortably among the top position players in the sport, and his speed adds a floor-raising element that few other shortstops in DFS can match. He pairs stolen bases with real home run pop, which is a rare combination in today’s game.

Tonight the Royals host the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium, where Witt faces a right-handed starter. According to RotoWire, Witt has been particularly effective against right-handers this season, which is precisely the matchup tonight. He draws attention from the Cardinals’ pitching staff as the Royals’ clear offensive centerpiece, but his contact rate and plate discipline mean he finds his way on base regardless of what approach opposing pitchers take. At $5,900 on DraftKings, Witt is priced like a premium play without quite the premium ownership that top-tier hitters typically carry.

Tanner Bibee, SP — Cleveland Guardians ($7,400 DraftKings)

Tanner Bibee is an interesting pivot off the more expensive pitching options today. His season numbers — a 4.17 ERA and 0-5 record — look ugly on the surface, but context matters enormously here. Bibee has been dramatically better at home than on the road: his 2026 home ERA sits at 1.63 compared to a brutal 8.15 away from Progressive Field. Tonight he takes the mound at home in Cleveland, facing a Cincinnati Reds lineup that will be traveling. His last start was an encouraging sign: six innings against Minnesota, one run allowed, nine strikeouts.

The value proposition at $7,400 is significant. He is projected as one of the stronger value pitchers on the slate with an expected DraftKings return of 2.37 points per $1,000 of salary. For DFS players who want to pay up at one pitcher spot (Schlittler) and spend down at the second, Bibee at home facing a divisional opponent is the optimal construction path. His 45 strikeouts over 45.1 innings this season show that the swing-and-miss ability is still there. Trust the home splits and build around him as your secondary SP tonight on DraftKings.

Travis Bazzana, 2B — Cleveland Guardians ($3,700 DraftKings)

Travis Bazzana was the first overall pick in the 2024 MLB Draft, and after lighting up Triple-A Columbus with a .287 average and .933 OPS across 24 games, he earned his call-up to Cleveland at the end of April. The 23-year-old second baseman brings a different kind of value to a DFS lineup: he does not beat you with raw power, but with elite plate discipline and stolen base ability that few hitters at this price range can replicate. In 14 MLB games, he has already stolen seven bases while posting a .407 OBP, and in the most recent seven-game stretch he has slashed .273/.467/.455.

At $3,700 on DraftKings, Bazzana projects at 2.46 points per $1,000 in salary, making him one of the best pure value plays at second base on today’s board. He is hitting in a Cleveland lineup that is home tonight and facing the Reds, and he gives your roster a genuine path to a stolen base upside that can change the trajectory of a lineup in both cash games and GPP formats. His youth and talent floor make the low ownership projection even more appealing for tournament play.

Building Your Lineup

The architecture for tonight’s DraftKings lineup starts with Schlittler locked in at SP1, eating the majority of your pitching salary budget. From there, Bibee as your secondary pitcher allows you to free up meaningful budget in the lineup. The Langeliers and Witt Jr. pairing gives you two premium hitters who are both producing at well above-average rates, and Bazzana rounds out the infield at minimum-viable cost without sacrificing upside.

For GPP stacks, consider targeting the Athletics lineup at Sutter Health Park against the Giants, building around Langeliers with Nick Kurtz and Tyler Soderstrom as supporting pieces. The Kansas City stack against the Cardinals is another angle if you want to get multiple Royals bats alongside Witt Jr. On FanDuel, the salary structure is slightly different but the same core principles apply: pay up for the best pitcher on the slate, identify the most exploitable opposing pitcher, and find the low-cost players with the highest stolen base upside to secure your salary cap floor. Tonight’s slate rewards those who plan ahead and lock in the core plays early, before confirmed lineups potentially shift ownership at the top of the DraftKings leaderboard.