Yankees vs. Blue Jays Same Game Parlay: Ben Rice HR, Two Yankees Hitters to Watch

The Yankees roll into Rogers Centre on Friday night with a chance to keep the pressure on in the AL East, and this is a matchup that sets up nicely for a parlay bettor who wants to lean on New York without needing a blowout to cash. First pitch is 7:15 PM ET, with Gerrit Cole taking the ball for the Yankees against Shane Bieber for Toronto. If you’re new to same-game parlays, this is a great one to learn on, because every leg here is built around things New York’s lineup has been doing all season.

The core idea of a same-game parlay, or SGP, is simple: instead of betting on one outcome, you combine several bets from the same game into a single ticket. All of them have to hit for the parlay to pay out, but because you’re stacking legs that reinforce each other — like a favorite winning plus a couple of hot hitters doing what they’ve done all year — the combined odds pay out much better than betting each piece separately. DraftKings promo code users have a four-leg SGP built for tonight: Yankees on the moneyline, Ben Rice to hit a home run, Luis Garcia to record a hit, and Heliot Ramos to record a hit.

Yankees Moneyline: Leaning on Cole Over Bieber

New York is the road favorite here, priced right around -148 to -155 depending on the book, with Toronto sitting as roughly a +126 to +138 underdog. That price tells you what oddsmakers think of this pitching matchup, and it’s not close. Gerrit Cole has been excellent this season, sitting at 6-5 with a 3.35 ERA and a strong strikeout rate that’s given Yankees hitters a cushion almost every time out. On the other side, Shane Bieber is working through a rough stretch in Toronto at 3-2 with a 5.48 ERA, a number that’s made life easier on opposing lineups all year.

The Yankees enter at 68-52 on the season, well ahead of a Blue Jays club at 59-63 that’s fighting just to stay above .500. When you combine a clearly better team with a clearly better starting pitcher, that’s exactly the kind of spot a moneyline anchor leg is built for in an SGP — you’re not trying to get cute with a run line or a big total, you’re just betting that the better team, with the better arm, wins the baseball game.

Ben Rice to Hit a Home Run

Ben Rice has quietly turned into one of the most dangerous power bats in the American League. He’s up to 32 home runs on the year, third in the AL, to go with 75 RBI and an .890 OPS — numbers that put him firmly in the middle of New York’s order as a legitimate power threat. Rice has had stretches of chasing more strikeouts since the All-Star break, but the raw pop hasn’t gone anywhere, and a Toronto pitching staff that’s already given up plenty of home runs this year against a righty-heavy Yankees lineup is a fair environment for him to add to that total.

Betting a “1+ home run” prop is a fun way to learn player props specifically, because it’s binary and easy to track — either he goes deep or he doesn’t, no partial credit needed. With Rice’s power numbers where they are, tying him into this parlay gives it some real upside on top of the safer moneyline piece.

Luis Garcia and Heliot Ramos to Record a Hit

The Yankees made two under-the-radar additions right before the trade deadline that have already started paying off. Luis Garcia came over from Washington and immediately made his presence felt, wearing No. 26 and hitting third in the order in his Yankees debut, going 2-for-4 with two RBI. He’s been a consistently high-contact hitter in 2026, and a “1+ hit” prop is about as friendly as a player prop gets — he just needs one knock in four or five at-bats.

Heliot Ramos arrived from San Francisco in the same deadline stretch, bringing outfield depth and a right-handed bat New York needed with injuries piling up around Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, and Giancarlo Stanton. Both Garcia and Ramos give this parlay two more realistic, everyday-type outcomes rather than anything requiring a huge individual performance — that’s exactly why “to record a hit” props are such a good starting point if you’re building your first SGP.

The Full Parlay

Put it all together and you’ve got a four-leg DraftKings SGP: Yankees Moneyline, Ben Rice 1+ Home Run, Luis Garcia 1+ Hit, and Heliot Ramos 1+ Hit. Check the DraftKings app for the exact combined price before you lock it in, since odds shift as game time approaches, but the appeal of this build is that every leg is grounded in something real — a favorite with a big pitching edge, a proven power bat, and two everyday hitters just needing to put one ball in play. That’s a formula worth remembering the next time you’re putting together your own MLB odds parlay.