The Penguins arrive in Dallas last in the Eastern Conference and carrying a goaltending question into one of the league’s best defensive rooms.

Quick take:

  • Pick: Under 6.5 total goals
  • Why: Dallas owns the league’s second-best penalty kill and a starter allowing 2.25 goals per game, and Pittsburgh’s power play ranks 25th.
  • The number to watch: Dallas’s 89.2% penalty kill, second in the NHL

Pittsburgh (7-13-2) lost 4-3 in Nashville on Saturday night, its third straight defeat, after jumping out to a 2-0 lead and then watching the second period come apart for the umpteenth time this season. Dallas (14-6-2) sits second in the Central with 30 points through 22 games, and the Stars have won four in a row heading into Sunday’s 7:00 PM ET puck drop at American Airlines Center.

The schedule adds to the problem. It is the second half of a back-to-back for the Penguins, who played in Nashville less than 24 hours earlier. Dallas has had two days of rest.

Stars Heavy Favorites, Total Sits at 6.5

The market has made its view clear. Dallas is around -225 on the moneyline at most books, with Pittsburgh priced near +185 to +190. The puck line has the Stars at -1.5 with plus-money returns, roughly +100 to +114. The total is 6.5, with the under priced around -120 to -130 at most shops and the over near even money.

That juice on the under tells you bettors have already noticed what the numbers say. Even so, a price like -125 only needs about a 55.6% hit rate to break even, and the matchup points to a better number than that.

Sunday, November 22 at 7:10 PMSpreadMoneyTotal
Pittsburgh Penguins
+1.5
(-139)
+190
O 6.5
(110)
Dallas Stars
-1.5
(105)
-225
U 6
(101)

Recent Form

Pittsburgh has dropped three straight and sits at the bottom of the East. Dallas shook off an 8-3 loss to Winnipeg on Nov. 15 with a run of tight, low-scoring wins, including a 2-0 shutout of Buffalo the next night. The tables below show what each side has done lately and how past meetings went.

DATE OPP CLOSE RESULT ATS/OU
Nov 21, 2026 @Nashville Predators +1.5 / 6.5 Lost 4-3 Won / Over
Nov 20, 2026 St Louis Blues +1.5 / 5.5 Lost 2-5 Lost / Over
Nov 15, 2026 Ottawa Senators -1.5 / 5.5 Lost 1-4 Lost / Under
Nov 12, 2026 @San Jose Sharks -1.5 / 6.5 Won 2-3 Lost / Under
Nov 9, 2026 @Anaheim Ducks +1.5 / 6.5 Lost 5-2 Lost / Over
Nov 8, 2026 @Los Angeles Kings +1.5 / 6.5 Won 2-5 Won / Over
Nov 6, 2026 Boston Bruins -1.5 / 6.5 Lost 2-6 Lost / Over
Nov 4, 2026 Vegas Golden Knights -1.5 / 6.5 Lost 2-3 Lost / Under
Oct 31, 2026 @Montréal Canadiens +1.5 / 8.5 Lost 5-4 Won / Over
Oct 29, 2026 Utah Mammoth +1.5 / 6.5 Lost 3-4 Won / Over

DATE OPP CLOSE RESULT ATS/OU
Nov 20, 2026 @Vegas Golden Knights +1.5 / 6.5 Won 3-4 Lost / Over
Nov 20, 2026 @Vegas Golden Knights +1.5 / 6.5 Won 3-4 Lost / Over
Nov 18, 2026 @Vegas Golden Knights +1.5 / 5.5 Won 3-4 Won / Over
Nov 16, 2026 Florida Panthers -1.5 / 5.5 Won 2-1 Lost / Under
Nov 15, 2026 Buffalo Sabres -1.5 / 5.5 Won 2-0 Won / Under
Nov 13, 2026 Winnipeg Jets -1.5 / 5.5 Lost 3-8 Lost / Over
Nov 8, 2026 San Jose Sharks -1.5 / 5.5 Won 4-3 Lost / Over
Nov 6, 2026 @Columbus Blue Jackets -1.5 / 5.5 Lost 2-1 Lost / Under
Nov 4, 2026 @Washington Capitals +1.5 / 5.5 Won 5-6 Lost / Over
Nov 1, 2026 Columbus Blue Jackets -2.5 / 6.5 Won 3-1 Lost / Under

Showing 10 of last 10 meetings

DATE TEAM OPP CLOSE RESULT ATS/OU
Oct 10, 2026 Pittsburgh Penguins @Dallas Stars +1.5 / 6.5 Won 2-1 Won / Under
Mar 28, 2026 Pittsburgh Penguins @Dallas Stars +1.5 / 6.5 Lost 3-6 Lost / Over
Dec 7, 2025 Dallas Stars @Pittsburgh Penguins -1.5 / 5.5 Won 3-2 Lost / Under
Apr 5, 2025 Dallas Stars @Pittsburgh Penguins -1.5 / 6.5 Lost 3-5 Lost / Over
Nov 12, 2024 Pittsburgh Penguins @Dallas Stars +1.5 / 6.5 Lost 1-7 Lost / Over
Mar 23, 2024 Dallas Stars @Pittsburgh Penguins -1.5 Won 4-2 Won / —
Oct 24, 2023 Pittsburgh Penguins @Dallas Stars +1.5 Lost 1-4 Lost / —
Mar 24, 2023 Dallas Stars @Pittsburgh Penguins -1.5 / 6.5 Won 3-2 Lost / Under
Dec 13, 2022 Pittsburgh Penguins @Dallas Stars -1.5 / 6.5 Won 2-1 Lost / Under
Jan 8, 2022 Dallas Stars @Pittsburgh Penguins +1.5 / 5.5 Won 3-2 Won / Under

Why the Under Has the Edge in Dallas

Start with special teams, because that is where this game is most likely to be decided. Dallas kills penalties at 89.2%, second in the NHL, having stopped 66 of 74 chances. Pittsburgh’s power play is clicking at 19.4%, which ranks 25th. When the Penguins get extra-man time, they are not likely to turn it into the kind of burst that blows up an under.

Dallas has gone to seven or more goals in only 7 of its 22 games.

In goal, Jake Oettinger is 12-4-1 with a 2.25 goals-against average and four shutouts, and he has started 17 of the Stars’ 22 games. He has handled Pittsburgh well in the past too, posting a .916 save percentage across four of the last five meetings. Casey DeSmith is the other option at 2.36 GAA, so neither Dallas goalie is a weakness.

Pittsburgh is the shakier side. Arturs Silovs holds a .873 save percentage and rookie Sergei Murashov sits at .894. Murashov made 25 saves in the Nashville loss, and the Penguins have rotated goalies on back-to-backs this season, so Silovs looks like the likelier Sunday starter. Neither team had confirmed its goalie at the time of writing.

The counterpoint is that Pittsburgh’s own games have been wide open. Thirteen of the Penguins’ 21 games before Saturday reached seven goals, and the Stars are thin on the back end, with Tyler Myers day-to-day and Lian Bichsel and Kyle Capobianco on injured reserve. Matt Duchene is out until January after core surgery.

Still, the Penguins are without Evgeni Malkin, Bryan Rust, Nick Robertson and Ryan Graves, which leaves the offense leaning on Erik Karlsson (19 points) and Tommy Novak (8 goals). That is not a lineup built to trade chances with a team that has a plus-rated goalie and a top-three penalty kill.

The likeliest path is Dallas controlling territory at home, with Mikko Rantanen (27 points) and Jason Robertson (26) doing their damage in short bursts rather than in a track meet. Dallas wins, but not by a basketball score.

The other piece is game script. Pittsburgh has been building early leads and then giving them back, and teams in that spot tend to get opened up in the middle frame. A tired Penguins group on the second night of a back-to-back is far more likely to defend in a shell once Dallas scores, and that style trims the total as much as it helps the favorite.

Prediction and Best Bet

Dallas is the clear side on paper. The Stars are rested, steadier in goal and playing a tired team that sits last in the East. Pittsburgh scores a couple, which keeps this from becoming a blowout, but Dallas’s penalty kill and goaltending cap the combined total.

The pick:

  1. Prediction: Penguins 2, Stars 4
  2. Best Bet: Under 6.5 total goals

A 4-2 final lands the under with a goal to spare, and anyone betting it can start with a DraftKings promo code to get a better price on the way in. For more lines across the league, check the live NHL odds.